HeroStats
Data is days old — Blizzard's rates page may be down or the daily update missed.
Echo

Echo

DAMAGE PC Console stats → dive C Tier
Win rate49.3%
Pick rate4.0%
Ban rate0.5%
Win rate, last 30 days +0.1% vs 7 days ago
Pick rate, last 30 days +0.1% vs 7 days ago

Versatile mobile DPS with a flight ability and powerful beam. Duplicate copies any enemy hero and inherits their ultimate — potentially the most impactful ult in the game.

Abilities
Tri-Shot Fires three shots in a triangle pattern.
Sticky Bombs Fires a volley of bombs that stick to enemies before detonating.
Flight Surges forward at high speed with full 3D directional control including vertical.
Focusing Beam Deadly beam that deals extra damage to targets below half health.
Duplicate Transforms into a targeted enemy hero with a rapidly charging ultimate.
Meta Analysis

Moderately skill-expressive: 2.2% win rate gain from Silver to Master, suggesting room to grow. Relatively even across game modes (Escort 49.9% to Control 48.7%). Best on Colosseo, Eichenwalde, Shambali Monastery — maps characterized by high-ground and chokepoint terrain, where their vertical mobility finds more angles in elevated terrain and open airspace. Struggles most on Midtown and Runasapi (multi-flank, high-ground, chokepoint, long sightlines maps).

Win Rate by Rank
Bronze
46.9%
Silver
48.3%
Gold
48.9%
Platinum
49.7%
Emerald
50.6%
Diamond
50.7%
Master
50.5%
Grandmaster
47.6%
Ban Rate by Rank
Bronze
0.8%
Silver
0.7%
Gold
0.5%
Platinum
0.4%
Emerald
0.4%
Diamond
0.4%
Master
0.4%
Grandmaster
0.3%
Win Rate by Map

± avg is Echo's win rate on the map minus their average across maps, adjusted for each map's overall shift (every hero runs a point or so below their average on the open Hybrids), so it compares across maps and matches the map pages. Kit fit (✓✓ … ✗✗) rates how well Echo's abilities suit each map's mode and geometry — independent of the observed win rates. Pick a rank to see Echo's map numbers at your level. Evaluate a pool with Echo →

Playing Echo at any rank? Strongest maps: Colosseo, Dorado, Route 66.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Colosseo Push
51.3% +1.8% ✓✓ 0.4%

Flight lets Echo cover Colosseo's long rotations and reach the fight first

Eichenwalde Hybrid
51.3% +2.9% – 0.6%
Shambali Monastery Escort
51.3% +1.6% – 0.5%
Dorado Escort
50.7% +1.0% ✓ 0.5%
Route 66 Escort
50.7% +1.0% ✓ 0.5%
Esperanca Push
50.5% +1.2% – 0.5%
Ilios Control
50.5% +1.0% – 0.6%
Paraiso Hybrid
50.2% +2.0% – 0.5%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
50.0% +0.5% ✓ 0.5%
Rialto Escort
49.9% +0.3% – 0.5%
Grimsvotn Escort
49.7% +0.2% – 0.5%
Circuit Royal Escort
49.6% +0.2% – 0.5%
Suravasa Flashpoint
49.6% +0.2% ✓ 0.5%
Hollywood Hybrid
49.5% +1.5% – 0.5%
New Junk City Flashpoint
49.4% +0.1% ✓ 0.4%
Nepal Control
49.1% -0.4% – 0.5%
New Queen Street Push
48.9% -0.5% – 0.5%
Junkertown Escort
48.8% -0.7% ✓ 0.5%
Numbani Hybrid
48.6% +0.5% – 0.6%
Samoa Control
48.6% -1.0% – 0.4%
Aatlis Flashpoint
48.4% -0.7% ✓ 0.4%
Busan Control
48.2% -1.4% – 0.5%
Lijiang Tower Control
48.2% -1.3% – 0.5%
Oasis Control
48.2% -1.2% – 0.4%
Kings Row Hybrid
48.1% -0.4% – 0.5%
Havana Escort
48.0% -1.4% – 0.5%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
47.8% -1.6% – 0.4%
Blizzard World Hybrid
47.6% -0.2% – 0.5%
Midtown Hybrid
47.4% -1.1% – 0.5%
Runasapi Push
47.2% -2.1% – 0.5%
Neon Junction Hybrid
46.7% -1.9% – 0.5%

Playing Echo at Bronze? Strongest maps: Colosseo, Route 66, Watchpoint Gibraltar.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Colosseo Push
51.8% +4.8% ✓✓ 1.0%

Flight lets Echo cover Colosseo's long rotations and reach the fight first

Antarctic Peninsula Control
51.3% +5.1% – 0.5%
Samoa Control
51.2% +4.5% – 1.1%
Kings Row Hybrid
50.7% +4.7% – 0.6%
Circuit Royal Escort
49.7% +3.0% – 0.7%
Route 66 Escort
49.4% +2.7% ✓ 1.0%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
49.4% +2.5% ✓ 0.8%
Nepal Control
49.1% +2.5% – 0.7%
Hollywood Hybrid
48.6% +2.9% – 0.7%
Paraiso Hybrid
48.3% +3.0% – 0.6%
Lijiang Tower Control
47.8% +1.3% – 0.7%
Ilios Control
47.5% +0.8% – 1.1%
Esperanca Push
47.3% +0.6% – 1.0%
Grimsvotn Escort
46.9% +0.3% – 0.7%
Dorado Escort
46.7% -0.4% ✓ 0.8%
New Junk City Flashpoint
46.7% -0.3% ✓ 0.7%
Midtown Hybrid
46.5% +0.6% – 0.8%
Shambali Monastery Escort
46.4% -0.2% – 0.7%
Numbani Hybrid
46.1% +0.7% – 0.9%
Havana Escort
46.0% -0.8% – 0.8%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
45.9% +0.2% – 0.7%
Runasapi Push
45.4% -1.2% – 0.7%
Neon Junction Hybrid
44.7% -1.3% – 0.8%
Oasis Control
44.7% -1.9% – 1.3%
Blizzard World Hybrid
44.1% -1.2% – 1.1%
Junkertown Escort
43.0% -3.7% ✓ 1.0%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Junkertown's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-3.7pp vs their average).

Busan Control
42.9% -3.7% – 1.0%
Rialto Escort
42.1% -4.6% – 0.6%
New Queen Street Push
41.7% -5.1% – 0.8%
Suravasa Flashpoint
40.2% -6.2% ✓ 0.9%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Suravasa stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-6.2pp vs their average).

Aatlis Flashpoint
37.0% -9.5% ✓ 0.6%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Aatlis stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-9.5pp vs their average).

Playing Echo at Silver? Strongest maps: New Junk City, Dorado, Colosseo.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
New Junk City Flashpoint
50.7% +2.2% ✓ 0.6%

Flashpoint's point scraps on New Junk City stay inside Tri-Shot range

Dorado Escort
50.5% +1.7% ✓ 0.6%

Flight lets Echo cover Dorado's long rotations and reach the fight first

Shambali Monastery Escort
50.5% +1.7% – 0.5%
Colosseo Push
50.4% +1.7% ✓✓ 0.6%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
50.2% +2.6% – 0.7%
Paraiso Hybrid
50.1% +2.8% – 0.8%
Route 66 Escort
50.0% +1.3% ✓ 0.7%
Suravasa Flashpoint
49.7% +1.1% ✓ 0.8%
Ilios Control
49.6% +1.1% – 0.7%
Rialto Escort
49.0% +0.5% – 0.6%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
48.9% +0.2% ✓ 0.7%
Samoa Control
48.8% +0.3% – 0.6%
Aatlis Flashpoint
48.6% -0.1% ✓ 0.7%
Blizzard World Hybrid
48.6% +1.8% – 0.7%
Havana Escort
48.4% -0.0% – 0.6%
Circuit Royal Escort
48.3% -0.2% – 0.6%
Nepal Control
48.3% -0.2% – 0.7%
Junkertown Escort
48.2% -0.5% ✓ 0.7%
Midtown Hybrid
48.0% +0.3% – 0.7%
Busan Control
47.5% -1.0% – 0.7%
New Queen Street Push
47.5% -1.0% – 0.7%
Esperanca Push
47.3% -1.2% – 0.5%
Grimsvotn Escort
47.0% -1.6% – 0.7%
Hollywood Hybrid
46.8% -0.4% – 0.6%
Lijiang Tower Control
46.8% -1.7% – 0.7%
Kings Row Hybrid
46.7% -0.8% – 0.6%
Runasapi Push
46.5% -2.0% – 0.7%
Numbani Hybrid
46.4% -0.8% – 0.8%
Oasis Control
46.2% -2.3% – 0.5%
Neon Junction Hybrid
46.1% -1.7% – 0.7%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
44.6% -3.8% – 0.7%

Playing Echo at Gold? Strongest maps: Dorado, New Queen Street, Route 66.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Eichenwalde Hybrid
52.1% +4.5% – 0.6%
Dorado Escort
50.7% +1.7% ✓ 0.5%

Flight lets Echo cover Dorado's long rotations and reach the fight first

Shambali Monastery Escort
50.7% +1.7% – 0.6%
Grimsvotn Escort
50.6% +1.6% – 0.5%
New Queen Street Push
50.3% +1.5% – 0.5%
Ilios Control
50.2% +1.4% – 0.5%
Route 66 Escort
50.2% +1.2% ✓ 0.6%
Numbani Hybrid
50.1% +2.7% – 0.5%
Colosseo Push
49.9% +1.0% ✓✓ 0.4%
Paraiso Hybrid
49.3% +2.0% – 0.5%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
49.3% +0.4% ✓ 0.4%
Hollywood Hybrid
49.2% +2.0% – 0.5%
Oasis Control
49.1% +0.3% – 0.5%
Junkertown Escort
49.0% +0.1% ✓ 0.4%
Rialto Escort
49.0% +0.1% – 0.4%
Lijiang Tower Control
48.5% -0.2% – 0.6%
Circuit Royal Escort
48.2% -0.5% – 0.5%
Samoa Control
48.2% -0.7% – 0.4%
Esperanca Push
47.9% -0.7% – 0.5%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
47.8% -1.1% – 0.5%
Nepal Control
47.8% -0.8% – 0.5%
Havana Escort
47.2% -1.6% – 0.5%
New Junk City Flashpoint
47.2% -1.9% ✓ 0.4%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on New Junk City stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-1.9pp vs their average).

Blizzard World Hybrid
47.0% -0.1% – 0.4%
Suravasa Flashpoint
46.9% -2.0% ✓ 0.5%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Suravasa stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-2.0pp vs their average).

Busan Control
46.7% -2.3% – 0.5%
Midtown Hybrid
46.5% -1.2% – 0.5%
Aatlis Flashpoint
46.4% -2.3% ✓ 0.4%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Aatlis stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-2.3pp vs their average).

Runasapi Push
46.1% -2.7% – 0.7%
Kings Row Hybrid
45.9% -1.9% – 0.5%
Neon Junction Hybrid
45.8% -2.2% – 0.6%

Playing Echo at Platinum? Strongest maps: Colosseo, Junkertown, Watchpoint Gibraltar.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Shambali Monastery Escort
53.3% +3.1% – 0.3%
Colosseo Push
52.3% +2.4% ✓✓ 0.4%

Flight lets Echo cover Colosseo's long rotations and reach the fight first

Esperanca Push
51.8% +2.1% – 0.4%
Junkertown Escort
51.8% +2.0% ✓ 0.5%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
51.8% +2.0% ✓ 0.5%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
51.5% +2.8% – 0.5%
Route 66 Escort
50.9% +0.9% ✓ 0.3%
Circuit Royal Escort
50.5% +0.7% – 0.5%
Dorado Escort
50.5% +0.6% ✓ 0.5%
Hollywood Hybrid
50.5% +2.3% – 0.4%
New Junk City Flashpoint
50.5% +0.9% ✓ 0.5%
Paraiso Hybrid
50.4% +1.8% – 0.4%
Ilios Control
50.2% +0.3% – 0.5%
Grimsvotn Escort
49.9% -0.0% – 0.4%
Nepal Control
49.9% -0.0% – 0.4%
Rialto Escort
49.8% -0.2% – 0.4%
Busan Control
49.5% -0.5% – 0.4%
Aatlis Flashpoint
49.4% -0.2% ✓ 0.3%
Suravasa Flashpoint
49.4% -0.5% ✓ 0.4%
Kings Row Hybrid
48.8% -0.0% – 0.4%
Oasis Control
48.8% -1.1% – 0.3%
Lijiang Tower Control
48.2% -1.7% – 0.4%
Midtown Hybrid
47.9% -0.8% – 0.4%
Samoa Control
47.8% -2.1% – 0.4%
Runasapi Push
47.7% -2.1% – 0.4%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
47.6% -2.2% – 0.3%
Havana Escort
47.6% -2.0% – 0.3%
New Queen Street Push
47.1% -2.6% – 0.4%
Neon Junction Hybrid
46.5% -2.5% – 0.4%
Blizzard World Hybrid
46.4% -1.7% – 0.4%
Numbani Hybrid
46.3% -2.0% – 0.4%

Playing Echo at Emerald? Strongest maps: Dorado, Route 66, Colosseo.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Dorado Escort
53.2% +2.4% ✓ 0.4%

Flight lets Echo cover Dorado's long rotations and reach the fight first

Route 66 Escort
52.7% +1.7% ✓ 0.5%
Circuit Royal Escort
52.1% +1.3% – 0.4%
Ilios Control
52.1% +1.4% – 0.4%
Rialto Escort
52.1% +1.1% – 0.5%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
52.0% +2.3% – 0.5%
Numbani Hybrid
52.0% +2.7% – 0.4%
Paraiso Hybrid
52.0% +2.4% – 0.4%
Colosseo Push
51.9% +1.2% ✓✓ 0.4%
Esperanca Push
51.9% +1.1% – 0.4%
Suravasa Flashpoint
51.8% +1.0% ✓ 0.4%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
51.7% +1.1% ✓ 0.3%
New Queen Street Push
51.6% +1.0% – 0.3%
Hollywood Hybrid
51.3% +2.2% – 0.4%
Shambali Monastery Escort
51.2% +0.2% – 0.3%
Kings Row Hybrid
50.7% +0.7% – 0.4%
Blizzard World Hybrid
50.6% +1.3% – 0.5%
Runasapi Push
50.5% -0.2% – 0.3%
Havana Escort
50.3% -0.4% – 0.4%
Aatlis Flashpoint
50.2% -0.2% ✓ 0.4%
Nepal Control
50.1% -0.8% – 0.3%
Grimsvotn Escort
49.6% -1.3% – 0.3%
Samoa Control
49.5% -1.6% – 0.3%
Busan Control
49.0% -1.9% – 0.3%
Neon Junction Hybrid
48.7% -1.4% – 0.3%
Oasis Control
48.6% -2.2% – 0.4%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
48.4% -2.4% – 0.3%
Midtown Hybrid
48.3% -1.5% – 0.3%
Junkertown Escort
48.1% -2.7% ✓ 0.3%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Junkertown's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-2.7pp vs their average).

Lijiang Tower Control
47.8% -3.2% – 0.4%
New Junk City Flashpoint
45.2% -5.4% ✓ 0.4%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on New Junk City stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-5.4pp vs their average).

Playing Echo at Diamond? Strongest maps: New Junk City, Colosseo, Suravasa.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
New Junk City Flashpoint
55.4% +4.5% ✓ 0.2%

Flashpoint's point scraps on New Junk City stay inside Tri-Shot range

Grimsvotn Escort
55.0% +4.0% – 0.4%
Shambali Monastery Escort
53.9% +3.1% – 0.4%
Colosseo Push
53.6% +3.0% ✓✓ 0.4%
Suravasa Flashpoint
53.3% +2.6% ✓ 0.4%
Rialto Escort
53.2% +2.0% – 0.4%
Busan Control
52.9% +1.6% – 0.3%
Esperanca Push
52.9% +2.4% – 0.4%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
52.6% +2.6% – 0.7%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
50.9% -0.1% – 0.3%
New Queen Street Push
50.9% +0.2% – 0.5%
Ilios Control
50.8% +0.2% – 0.7%
Paraiso Hybrid
50.8% +1.1% – 0.4%
Havana Escort
50.7% +0.3% – 0.2%
Numbani Hybrid
50.7% +1.6% – 0.7%
Hollywood Hybrid
50.6% +0.9% – 0.5%
Nepal Control
50.5% -0.7% – 0.4%
Dorado Escort
50.2% -0.2% ✓ 0.5%
Lijiang Tower Control
50.1% -1.0% – 0.3%
Route 66 Escort
50.1% -0.8% ✓ 0.3%
Neon Junction Hybrid
50.0% -0.1% – 0.2%
Aatlis Flashpoint
49.6% -0.7% ✓ 0.4%
Blizzard World Hybrid
49.6% +0.7% – 0.3%
Kings Row Hybrid
48.4% -1.8% – 0.3%
Runasapi Push
48.2% -2.3% – 0.4%
Circuit Royal Escort
47.5% -3.0% – 0.3%
Samoa Control
47.3% -4.1% – 0.1%
Oasis Control
47.2% -3.6% – 0.3%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
47.1% -3.2% ✓ 0.6%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Watchpoint Gibraltar's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-3.2pp vs their average).

Junkertown Escort
46.1% -4.3% ✓ 0.2%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Junkertown's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-4.3pp vs their average).

Midtown Hybrid
44.6% -5.4% – 0.2%

Playing Echo at Master? Strongest maps: Route 66, Esperanca, Colosseo.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Route 66 Escort
60.0% +9.1% ✓ 0.0%

Flight lets Echo cover Route 66's long rotations and reach the fight first

Circuit Royal Escort
57.1% +5.9% – 0.2%
Esperanca Push
57.0% +6.3% – 0.4%
Paraiso Hybrid
56.6% +6.4% – 0.0%
Rialto Escort
56.1% +5.4% – 0.4%
Blizzard World Hybrid
55.7% +5.7% – 0.5%
Midtown Hybrid
55.4% +6.0% – 0.3%
Numbani Hybrid
55.2% +5.7% – 0.6%
Grimsvotn Escort
54.6% +3.3% – 0.4%
Hollywood Hybrid
54.2% +3.8% – 0.6%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
53.4% +3.6% – 0.7%
New Queen Street Push
53.0% +2.2% – 0.4%
Colosseo Push
52.8% +2.0% ✓✓ 0.4%
Neon Junction Hybrid
51.6% +1.4% – 0.5%
Ilios Control
51.0% +0.3% – 0.7%
Lijiang Tower Control
50.1% -1.0% – 0.3%
Samoa Control
49.6% -1.5% – 0.3%
Havana Escort
49.5% -0.9% – 0.4%
Oasis Control
49.1% -1.8% – 0.3%
New Junk City Flashpoint
48.7% -2.0% ✓ 0.2%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on New Junk City stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-2.0pp vs their average).

Aatlis Flashpoint
48.5% -1.9% ✓ 0.3%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Aatlis stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-1.9pp vs their average).

Busan Control
48.2% -3.1% – 0.3%
Kings Row Hybrid
48.0% -2.1% – 0.5%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
47.8% -3.5% – 0.2%
Suravasa Flashpoint
47.5% -3.3% ✓ 0.4%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Suravasa stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-3.3pp vs their average).

Nepal Control
46.4% -4.9% – 0.4%
Dorado Escort
46.1% -3.1% ✓ 1.1%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Dorado's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-3.1pp vs their average).

Shambali Monastery Escort
43.5% -7.7% – 0.4%
Junkertown Escort
42.2% -8.0% ✓ 0.3%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Junkertown's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-8.0pp vs their average).

Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
39.4% -10.8% ✓ 0.4%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Watchpoint Gibraltar's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-10.8pp vs their average).

Runasapi Push
38.9% -11.6% – 0.5%

Playing Echo at Grandmaster? Strongest maps: Junkertown, Watchpoint Gibraltar, Aatlis.

Map Mode Win rate ↓ ± avg Kit fit Bans
Blizzard World Hybrid
61.3% +15.7% – 0.0%
Junkertown Escort
56.7% +13.4% ✓ 0.0%

Flight lets Echo cover Junkertown's long rotations and reach the fight first

Rialto Escort
56.7% +9.3% – 0.6%
Watchpoint Gibraltar Escort
55.1% +9.3% ✓ 0.0%
Aatlis Flashpoint
55.0% +8.5% ✓ 0.4%
Esperanca Push
54.2% +6.9% – 0.2%
Ilios Control
53.7% +6.4% – 0.7%
New Junk City Flashpoint
53.3% +5.7% ✓ 0.4%
Numbani Hybrid
52.6% +9.2% – 1.7%↑
Oasis Control
52.1% +4.7% – 0.4%
Shambali Monastery Escort
49.8% +1.6% – 0.0%
Circuit Royal Escort
49.7% +2.7% – 0.4%
Samoa Control
48.5% +1.4% – 0.4%
Grimsvotn Escort
47.2% -0.5% – 0.1%
New Queen Street Push
47.2% +0.1% – 0.1%
Nepal Control
47.0% -1.0% – 0.3%
Suravasa Flashpoint
46.2% -1.7% ✓ 0.3%

On paper Flashpoint's point scraps on Suravasa stay inside Tri-Shot range — but the numbers disagree (-1.7pp vs their average).

Dorado Escort
46.0% -1.0% ✓ 0.8%
Kings Row Hybrid
45.4% -0.7% – 0.2%
Antarctic Peninsula Control
45.1% -1.8% – 0.2%
Runasapi Push
44.0% -2.8% – 0.0%
Lijiang Tower Control
43.7% -3.7% – 0.3%
Paraiso Hybrid
43.6% -1.4% – 1.0%
Busan Control
43.5% -4.1% – 0.1%
Route 66 Escort
43.3% -2.9% ✓ 0.5%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Route 66's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-2.9pp vs their average).

Hollywood Hybrid
39.1% -5.4% – 0.5%
Eichenwalde Hybrid
37.4% -8.3% – 0.0%
Midtown Hybrid
36.9% -9.7% – 0.6%
Colosseo Push
35.6% -11.1% ✓✓ 0.5%

On paper Flight lets Echo cover Colosseo's long rotations and reach the fight first — but the numbers disagree (-11.1pp vs their average).

Neon Junction Hybrid
28.8% -16.9% – 0.0%
Havana Escort
22.1% -21.8% – 0.9%
Compare Echo with